Get the Recipe
For years I've looked longingly in the direction of pecan pie, but with a tree nut allergy, it's a love that will remain unrequited. I've tried to fill that sticky pie gap in my heart with substitutes, notably Shoo-fly Pie and the Black Bottom Oat Pie from Four & Twenty Blackbirds in Brooklyn. Recently I learned of a Peanut Pie that hails from Virginia and the Carolinas that sounded just like the nuts + sweet goo that I crave. Naturally this pie moved to the top of my to-make list.
As far as pie goes, it's pretty darn simple to make: just roll out and blind bake your favorite butter crust recipe, add some dark, dark chocolate and a simple gooey filling then top with split peanuts and bake until the center sets. The pie itself is a study in textures from the crunchy peanut brittle-like top to the gooey center and flakey crust. The chocolate, peanut, and sweet goo combo is reminiscent of a candy bar come to life (in pie form) with an added air of sophistication from the molasses. While I can't give you a direct head-to-head with pecan pie, my husband assures me that the comparison is apt and that he wouldn't pass up a slice of either.
Get the Recipe
Got a favorite classic American dessert recipe you'd like to see featured here? Email us with the subject: "American Classics."
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.