Get the Recipe
Here's the thing about cookies and cream. Everyone likes it, but no one really loves it. I mean, no one says that their last bite of ice cream on earth would be cookies and cream. No one gets into the deconstructive analytics of what makes amazing cookies and cream ice cream. Because there's a simple problem: Oreos, the most common cookie element of cookies and cream, already have a cream component. Sticking them in ice cream just feels a little redundant. Rule One of ice cream making: a flavor should be intensified, not diluted, by churning it into ice cream.*
* And Rule Zero: stop asking if you can make a low-fat version.
We've addressed this problem on Scooped before with a coffee-spiked cookies and cream that was honestly pretty aces. But it's warmer now and I'm looking for something more refreshing. So: enter mint Oreo ice cream.
Sure, you've seen mint and chocolate combined before. But the meeting of slightly bitter cocoa cookie and leafy, grassy cream steeped with a generous bundle of real mint leaves is pretty special. Fresh from the churn, this stuff is dangerous: so cool and ethereal and fresh that you could down most of the quart right there. But be patient, stir in your cookies, and give the freezer a few hours to work its magic. The mint and cocoa benefit enormously from their alone time, and the Oreos soften to an almost fudge-like consistency.
Oreo Week: you came and went so fast we hardly knew you. But as far as I'm concerned you'll live on through this ice cream.
Get the Recipe
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.