Preserved: Classic Mint Jelly


Capture the best of your seasonal produce for later.

Get the Recipe

If you're planning to serve grilled or roasted lamb for Easter dinner, skip the neon green, store-bought mint jelly and whip up this simple homemade version. Mildly sweet and pleasingly tart, it bursts with fresh mint flavor.

When I was growing up, every year on Easter Sunday my mother would dig the same jar of mint jelly out of the back of the refrigerator. I can still remember its florescent lime color, and the way it congealed and crusted around the lid. Yuck. Who would want to smear that on a perfectly seared spring lamb chop?

But there is no denying that the fresh, verdant flavor of mint is a natural compliment to rich, succulent lamb. This year I got to thinking, could I improve upon the artificial tasting, store-bought version?

First things first: I knew the green food coloring had to go. I also knew I wanted to cut back a bit on the amount of sugar. Mint jelly should be sweet, but not so sweet that it infringes upon the inherently savory nature of a lamb dinner.

Some recipes I researched called for extracting pectin from granny smith apples. While I liked this all-natural approach, the process took several hours. I was looking for something quick and simple. Other recipes called for copious amounts of green food coloring, or as many as 7 cups of sugar. Eugenia Bone published a terrific-sounding recipe for Jalapeño-Mint Jelly in Food & Wine, but I wanted to make a classic, traditional version. Finally, I found a recipe from the book Putting Food By by Ruth Hertzberg, Janet Greene, and Beatrice Vaughan. It called for 2 cups of mint (more than most other recipes) and only 2 cups of sugar (less than most). Best of all, it could be prepared from start to finish in about an hour.

This mint jelly has a muted, golden hue not unlike that of chamomile tea. If you must, add a single drop of green food coloring, which will impart a natural-looking pale green color. After the Easter feast, use the jelly to pump up cold lamb sandwiches, or combine it with fresh lime juice to make a mojito-inspired glaze for grilled shrimp.

Get the Recipe

Classic Mint Jelly »

About the Author: Lucy Baker is a food writer and the author of The Boozy Baker: 75 Recipes for Spirited Sweets. She is currently at work on a second book about homemade food gifts. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband and dachshund.